Page 3

 

 

TABLE 3. Samuel’s Missing 37 Years

Event

Years in Josephus

Years in Rabbinic Figures

 

 

 

 

 

 

Eli judges Israel

  40

4:18

 

40

 

Ark taken, Samuel rules alone

20

7:12-13

 

20

 

Philistines subdued until Samuel is old

  18

8:1

 

 

 

Saul (war on Philistines  12)

12

13:1; 14:52

 

 

 

David rules in Hebron (Saul’s war on Philistines 6)

  7

28:3

 

 

 

David brings ark into Jerusalem in his 8th yr.

   57

 

 

 

 

David rules in Jerusalem 33 years.

33

 

 

33

 

Solomon founds the temple in his 4th year

   3

 

 

   3

 

  

93

Yrs. after Eli

 

56

 

 

Exodus to the Temple 251 Years?
Or was Exodus to the capture of Jerusalem 251 Years?

We have traced a continuous 251-year pattern from Adam down to Solomon’s temple. Josephus, Eusebius and Ussher all end their era of the exodus in the fourth year of Solomon, when the temple was founded (see I Kings 6:1).

There is an alternative view, which adds 36 years between the death of Eli and the temple.

The rabbinic version says that, at Eli’s death, the Ark was taken to the house of Abinadab for 20 years (I Sam. 7:2), until David brought it into Jerusalem from the house of Abinadab (1 Chron. 13:7). Thereafter, David ruled in Jerusalem 33 years. And Solomon founded the temple in his fourth year, 56 years after the death of Eli. This would define Solomon’s 4th year as the 56th year after Eli’s death (20 + 36 = 56), 251 years after the Exodus.

However, Josephus says, after Eli’s death, the Ark was at the house of Abinadab 20 years, and David brought the Ark into Jerusalem after 56 years, 36 years before the temple.  This could possibly mean that David actually brought the Ark into Jerusalem 251 years after the Exodus and that Solomon’s temple was 93 years after Eli’s death (57 + 36) (251 + 36) as in TABLE 3. So there is confusion over David's 7th year (now believed to be in 1004 BC) and Solomon’s 12th year (Ussher’s year 1004 BC).

In contrast, Eusebius’ view places Solomon’s temple 1004 years before Herod’s temple begun in 18 BC, which would be 1022 BC (502 years before 520 BC).

Ussher’s view places Solomon’s temple at 1012 BC. Again, all years of the kings are assumed to be consecutive, not contemporary or overlapping. Because the kings overlapped, Solomon’s 4th year was in 968, not 1012.

After 40 years in the wilderness, there were 83 years for Moses, Joshua and the elders (according to Josephus), and 111 years for the oppressions (including the judges, the last judge, Eli) and 57 years for Samuel and Saul down to David’s 7th year, when he captured Jerusalem (83 + 111 + 57 = 251).

If the 251 years after the Exodus ended 36 years earlier than 968 BC, that is, in 1004 BC, then the Exodus would have been in 1255 BC (968 + 36 = 1004) (1004 BC + 251 = 1255).

If the 479 years after the Exodus ended 36 years earlier, in 1004 BC, then the Exodus would have been in 1484 BC (968 + 480 = 1448) (1448 + 36 = 1484).

If the 590 years after the Exodus ended 36 years earlier, in 1004 BC, then the Exodus would have been in 1594 BC (968 + 590 = 1558) (1558 + 36 = 1594).

 

 

Next

Page 1

Page 2

Page 3

Page 4

Page 5

Page 6

Page 7

Page 8

Page 9

Page 10

 

 

Page 11

Page 12

Page 13

Page 14

Page 15

Page 16

Page 17

Page 18

Page 19

Page 20